The Gift of Grief: Coming to God with Your Broken Heart

Introduction

Lisa Harper admits it straight out: she ended up being grateful for her grief. It's a sentence that seems almost out of place. You don't thank God for what breaks you. And yet, in the season she's walking through (one month after losing someone she loved deeply), she testifies that it's there, in that gap between "I'm waiting on God" and "he hasn't answered yet," that she met the Lord in a new way. This message doesn't try to beautify pain. It offers you something else: daring to bring God what you usually hide, and encountering a Father who doesn't turn away from your tears.

Message outline

1. The lie that "sad = bad"

Many Christians inherited this unwritten conviction: a good disciple keeps a smile, verse-printed T-shirt included, and never talks about the hard days.
Lisa Harper admits she lived this way for years: selecting her emotions, bringing God only the bright colors, hiding the black and blue of her heart.
This fear rests on a lie: that God would be disappointed in us when we're sad. But nowhere in Scripture does he ask us to suppress our pain to present only the shiny parts.
On the contrary, he says: "Bring me everything." Sadness honestly expressed before God damages neither his reputation nor your faith.

2. Orthodoxy, orthopraxy, orthopathy: when our emotions join our convictions

Three words from classical theology. Orthodoxy: believing rightly, having convictions anchored in Scripture. Orthopraxy: acting rightly, in consistency with what you believe.
Orthopathy: feeling rightly. That is, letting our emotions come under God's gaze without locking them into an "acceptable" or "unacceptable" category.
Many stumble on this third dimension. We've been taught that "faith is not a feeling" (that's true), and concluded that we must silence every difficult emotion. Wrong.
Lisa shares how a torn tendon in her arm earned her this word from the surgeon: "Everything needs to realign." Our walk with God is like that: when the heart stays misaligned with what the head professes, something suffers. The coherence between faith and emotion is built in honesty.

3. Elijah under the broom tree: when God doesn't reprimand, he feeds

On Mount Carmel, Elijah witnesses one of the greatest miracles of the Old Testament. The fire of God descends, consumes the sacrifice, the water, and even the stones (1 Kings 18).
The next day, he receives a death threat from Jezebel. He flees into the wilderness, sits under a broom tree, and asks to die: "It is enough! Now, Lord, take my life."
Heaven's response is not a reprimand. Elijah falls asleep; an angel touches him, tells him to eat. He eats, lies down again. The angel returns a second time: get up and eat some more. God does not punish him for being at the end of his rope. He feeds him and lets him sleep.
That God is the same today. When you're down, he doesn't start by listing your shortcomings. He draws near, with a piece of bread and some rest.

4. Psalm 22 comes before Psalm 23

We gladly embroider Psalm 23 · "The Lord is my shepherd", on a cushion. We forget that David first wrote Psalm 22: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"
The two psalms follow each other, from the same author. The lament opens the way to trust. One doesn't contradict the other: it makes it livable.
More psalms are laments than songs of victory. The Bible makes room for honest complaint. It's a model for Christian prayer, not a weakness.
Bringing God a heart melted like wax is not contradictory to believing he is good. It's recognizing that today, you need to be carried.

5. Don't suffer alone

When Elijah flees, he makes a mistake: he leaves his servant in Beersheba and goes alone into the wilderness. It's not his sadness that's the problem, it's the isolation.
The enemy of our souls whispers: "No one would understand." That's the lie that prolongs the pain. Find someone to whom you can say: "I'm sad. I'm angry. My prayer seems to bounce off the ceiling."
Lisa tells a childhood memory. After her parents' difficult divorce, she had sworn never to cry in front of her mother. One day, hidden under her bed, she sobs. Her mother hears her, stretches out beside her, under the bed frame, without a word. Just her presence, shoulder to shoulder.
This is the picture of what God does, and what the church can be: not bringing ready-made answers, but a presence. "The Lord is close to the brokenhearted" (Psalm 34:18).

Key takeaways

Being sad before God is not a flaw in your faith. It's an invitation to bring him all the colors of your heart, including the darkest ones.
A solid faith connects three dimensions: what you believe, how you act, and what you feel. Emotional honesty is the key to coherence.
When you're at the end of your rope, God doesn't start by reproaching you. Just as he did for Elijah, he draws near to feed you and give you rest.
Psalm 22 comes before Psalm 23. Lamenting before God doesn't cancel trust, it prepares it.
Don't cry alone. Isolation is a lie from the enemy. Find a brother, a sister, a pastor to whom you can tell the truth.

Personal application

Is there a sadness, a grief, a disappointment you're carrying without daring to talk about it, even to God? Dare to bring it to him today, without dressing it up.
Of your three dimensions (what you believe, how you act, what you feel), which one is most out of alignment right now? What would it take to bring coherence back?
Take 10 minutes to read Psalm 22 out loud. Identify the words that describe what you're feeling and make them your prayer.
Who, in your Christian community, really knows how you're doing? Is there someone you can tell this week: "I'm not doing well, pray for me"?
Looking back on your faith journey, can you recognize a season where it was at the bottom of the pit that God drew closest? Take a moment to thank him for it.

Verses cited

Frequently asked questions

Is it contrary to faith to be sad or angry before God?

No. Scripture is woven through with laments: more than a third of the Psalms are complaints addressed to God. Job, Jeremiah, David, Elijah, and even Jesus in the garden of Gethsemane expressed their distress to the Father. Suppressing sadness in the name of faith doesn't make you stronger; it widens the gap between what you confess and how you live. Bringing God your broken heart in all honesty is an authentic act of faith. This message is translated from an English-language sermon by Lisa Harper, preached at Elevation Church.

How can I experience God's presence when he doesn't answer my prayer?

This is precisely what Lisa Harper calls "the gap": the time between "I'm waiting on God" and "he has answered." In that space, the Bible doesn't promise explanations, but a presence: "The Lord is close to the brokenhearted" (Psalm 34:18). Like a mother who silently slides under her child's bed, God sits beside you. His closeness doesn't depend on your performance or your mood. It is the foundation, not the reward.

What can I do to not walk through grief in isolation?

The first thing not to do is what Elijah did after Mount Carmel: go alone into the wilderness. Name your suffering to at least one trusted person in your church, a pastor, a group leader, a spiritual friend. Ask to be prayed for, not in an abstract way in a notebook, but concretely, today, in your present situation. The church is made to lift the stretcher of those who can no longer stand on their own. Accepting to be carried is not weakness: it's the normal functioning of the body of Christ.

All articles on “Faith”

to take notes and ask questions.